Consultants' Corner

Quality Over Quantity and Social Media Engagement

Terry Golesworthy
Insurance Experts' Forum, May 22, 2012

“Engagement” is the buzzword of the day in social media. Brands have shifted their focus from recruiting fans and followers to creating dialogues with them. The hypothesis is that engaged fans will see the organization as more than a vendor of financial services products.

Indeed, in a survey of members, Thrivent found that 42 percent of people age 45 and younger are more likely to consult the company about financial matters because of its presence on Facebook.

Engagement, however, is not that simple; most insurers struggle to work out with whom they want to have a dialogue. Simply being a customer is not a compelling reason to have a conversation—account questions, maybe, but surely they are handled better via a telephone call.

On Facebook, the average number of interactions (a like, share or comment) by fans to an insurers post is a little more than three per 100 fans. This number, as with all averages, hides a very complex picture since engagement can come in many forms.

A common bond that exists with natural communities is an obvious advantage for “let’s chat” conversations, and fraternal- and membership-based organizations such as Thrivent Financial, Modern Woodmen of America and USAA enjoy higher engagement levels (5.3 interactions per 100 fans, or 5.3 percent). Even higher engagement (12 percent) comes from pages that focus on lifestyle or occupation; good examples are found on the Facebook pages of Allstate Motorcycle, Acuities InGear for truckers and Horace Mann for teachers. Fans visiting these pages see beyond the insurance policy and into the community.

Social media engagement does not need to be a conversation or community, however; it can be the virtual equivalent of a high-five. This is prevalent among the industry mass marketers that often accrue huge fan bases, thus rendering conversation a largely implausible goal. Flo, with more than 4 million fans on Facebook, can do little more than post content interesting enough to draw a smile or attract a like. Engagement rates are generally low (a little more than 1 percent), with Mayhem from Allstate as the current undisputed leader.

Another form of engagement is to “pass the parcel”—creating content compelling enough that the recipient immediately passes it on to his or her network. This can expand a page's reach dramatically, while also providing content for each person in the chain. This works effectively in the insurance industry because so much already builds on the distributed model.

Agents are quickly recognizing the value of social media for keeping in touch with the connected consumer, but often struggle to develop a steady flow of interesting content. Insurers that address this agent need are enjoying strong engagement rates, especially from shares. Auto-Owners Insurance not only have an engagement rate of 35 percent, but 60 percent of that is the result of content shares. AGLA and Primerica also boast high engagement rates, and like Auto-Owners, the vast majority is with content-starved agents. In a recent survey of 293 independent agencies by B.H. Burke & Co., 60 percent have a Facebook page and 37 percent a Twitter feed. The problem is that 68 percent of those with social media activity have no plan.

Therefore, before embarking on social media and engagement measurements, it is critical to understand which community you most want to engage. Success, or lack of it, is very often the result of attempting to speak to multiple audiences and, as a result, speaking to none.

This blog was posted with the permission of the Customer Respect Group.

Terry Golesworthy, president of The Customer Respect Group, has covered technology issues and innovations in the insurance industry for many years.

Readers are encouraged to respond to Terry using the “Add Your Comments” box below. He also can be reached at terry@customerrespect.com.

The opinions of bloggers on www.insurancenetworking.com do not necessarily reflect those of Insurance Networking News.

Comments (0)

Be the first to comment on this post using the section below.

Add Your Comments...

Already Registered?

If you have already registered to Insurance Networking News, please use the form below to login. When completed you will immeditely be directed to post a comment.

Forgot your password?

Not Registered?

You must be registered to post a comment. Click here to register.

Blog Archive

Mobile Device Management – Find That Middle Ground

There's a tug of war over BYOD, but neither those in favor nor those against should tug too hard.

Social Media for Insurers — Stop Counting and Start Measuring

Measuring goes beyond just accumulating fans and followers: it looks at the contribution to business.

Vendors Embrace Mobile Technology

IT leaders at software firms clearly recognize the importance of mobility to drive their businesses forward. Almost 70 percent see mobility as mission critical or important to their organization today.

Digital Vision vs. Harsh Reality

Much work remains to reconcile insurers' digital vision with the digital reality that seems to be arriving for other industries.

Big Data Is Paying Off

Insurers are getting business benefit out of their big data projects, but these projects alone won't grow their business.

What Can Insurers Learn from Home Depot?

The latest cyber-attack highlights the importance of helping policy holders defend themselves.