Customer Loyalty—The Holy Grail in UK Personal Lines Insurance

Catherine Stagg-Macey
Insurance Experts' Forum, March 9, 2010

The topic of customer loyalty made an unsurprising appearance at recent conference of UK senior marketing executives. In several conversations, and breakout groups, the executives mused how different business might look in the UK if the consumer wasn’t very unloyal. Growth is an important factor for UK in 2010, and the aspiration for lower customer churn is not surprising.

So how did we get to a point where most consumers know it’s better to change insurers every year? Well, the consumer has learned that loyalty is usually rewarded with a hike in their premium. I’ve experienced this first-hand, finding out with some online research that my same insurer would take me back as a “new customer” at a lower rate than their renewal offer to me.

The Internet has democratized the renewal process. Given some time, access to the Internet, the consumer can check across the market, with the use of one or two aggregator Web sites. And they do use more than one—research suggests most use 2.8 to 3 aggregator Web sites to find the best price. This is an extraordinary investment in time to get a better deal. It also highlights the very “grudge” nature of an insurance purchase.

The aggregators appear to have caused the insurers to jump into the dire race of competing purely on price. Whilst many aggregators defend their position of being able to offer comparisons in more areas than price, my straw poll of friends shows that they look for a recognized brand in the top five (i.e. cheapest).

The visual comes to mind of the cartoon sheep/dog/coyote racing over the edge of the cliff, taking a few seconds to realize where they are, and looking down at the vast blue space beneath them. It strikes me that’s where UK insurers are today—realizing they have run out of cliff and it’s an awful long way down to the dark blue sea.

These sentiments were reiterated at the marketing conference. “This has to end,” said one chief marketing officer, “it’s just not sustainable.” A U.S. colleague told an amazed audience how her insurer had covered the whole family (motor, house and term life) since she was in college. They now insure her college-aged daughter, and offer her a discount because she gets good grades (proven link between claim propensity and grades apparently!). The family was a real fan of this large insurer.

There were no shortage of good ideas to encourage and reward customer loyalty. But the clear risk that remained unanswered was that any insurer taking a line contrary to the market was likely to be punished by the consumer in the short term. In the medium to long-term, lower customer churn would be better for their profitability, but a listed company performing to quarterly and annual reports can be very limited to any long-term plays such as this.

I hope UK insurers crack this tricky problem. If for no other reason than I find it tedious investing two to three hours a year looking for a new insurer. And the larger message to other markets who are moving steadily toward the low-cost producer model: Watch your feet; you may find yourself running out of runway before you know it, and it’s very painful to claw your way back.

This blog has been reprinted with permission from Celent. Catherine Stagg-Macey is a senior analyst in Celent's insurance practice, and can be reached at

The opinions of bloggers on do not necessarily reflect those of Insurance Networking News.

Comments (3)


Posted by: william j | July 24, 2010 2:55 PM

Report this Comment

Holy Grail of Residuals or HGR is a legit online business. It's not a scam... You must be an open minded person and you definitely need to do your home work and try to research about this business. It is human nature to be doubtful about something. HGR is 100% FREE to take the tour so check it out and see it for your self. Feel free to visit

For additional information on how to become successful with Holy Grail of Residuals, we can show you how you can do it for FREE!!!!

Posted by: william j | July 24, 2010 2:53 PM

Report this Comment

I worked as an underwriter for large direct writer when the buying public thought they offered the cheapest personal lines policy because they said so on television. In those days the twenty year insured was common and treated with kid gloves. It took a senior underwriter review and approval from a district manager to non-renew. This arrangement did result in an insured/carrier loyalty that seemed nice then but was only possible because of a lack of accessible information. In today's market with little carrier/insured loyalty it is a must that insurance companies include pricing when evaluating the effectiveness of their customer service.

Posted by: Robert R | March 13, 2010 12:28 PM

Report this Comment

Add Your Comments...

Already Registered?

If you have already registered to Insurance Networking News, please use the form below to login. When completed you will immeditely be directed to post a comment.

Forgot your password?

Not Registered?

You must be registered to post a comment. Click here to register.

Blog Archive

Living with the Internet of Things (and crowd funding)

The Internet of Things has it’s teething problems.

6 Technology Priorities for Individual Life Carriers

While many aging, generally mainframe-based systems, remain capable of supporting basic policy processing and accounting functions, the costs associated with enhancing them are becoming increasingly problematic.

With Google Favoring Mobile, Will The Industry Take it Seriously?

Google’s search engine will now will favor mobile friendly content over traditional website content; within the insurance industry, the greatest initial impact is likely to be felt by insurance distributors.

Why Some Technologists Get Cold Feet on Mobile

There are those who believe that favoring one channel or mode over another will lead to even more silos and dysfunction than we already have in many organizations.

Insurance IT Spending and Budgeting Benchmarks

New research from Novarica highlights areas of concern and offers insights on insurers spending and budgeting decisions.

Enterprise Mobilemania Continues Unabated

More than half of companies are spending more on developing mobile applications -- but are they more efficient?