Editors' Cuts

The Heartland Hullabaloo

Bill Kenealy
Insurance Experts' Forum, February 19, 2012

As insurance and reinsurance companies fret about the potential impact of climate change on their bottom lines, they face a countervailing wind emanating from flacks working for those with a vested interest in the status quo.

I was reminded of this on Wednesday when an indignant press release from the reliably windy Heartland Institute hit my inbox. In case you missed it, it seems somebody tricked a staffer at Heartland, a think tank with contrarian views on climate change, into sending embarrassing internal documents to a new e-mail address. Said documents, some of which may be fake, wound up on the Web and hilarity ensued.

Considering Heartland’s role in hyping the stolen e-mail abetted Climategate scandal, the florid response to its own misfortune is an instant classic in the annals of hypocrisy and self pity. “We respectfully ask all activists, bloggers, and other journalists to immediately remove all of these documents and any quotations taken from them, especially the fake “climate strategy” memo and any quotations from the same, from their blogs, Web sites, and publications, and to publish retractions,” the release states. “The individuals who have commented so far on these documents did not wait for Heartland to confirm or deny the authenticity of the documents. We believe their actions constitute civil and possibly criminal offenses for which we plan to pursue charges and collect payment for damages, including damages to our reputation. We intend to find this person and see him or her put in prison for these crimes.”

Is that all? No flogging or smiting of the first born? Heartland’s cri de coeur then goes on to lecture us all on common decency and journalistic ethics; you know, the type displayed by Heartland Institute President and CEO Joseph Bast when he labeled former Utah Governor and Republican nomination for President Jon Huntsman “stupid” for believing the scientific consensus on climate change.

My question to the perpetrators: Why go to the trouble to defame and discredit Heartland when it does such a good job doing it on its own? Think tanks are notorious for intellectual dishonesty and churning out “research” nakedly tailored to the interests of their donors, such as the dubious studies questioning the link between smoking and cancer produced at the behest of tobacco companies. Not surprisingly, a quick perusal of Heartland’s donor list reveals a good many of the world’s most profitable energy companies

Much like politicians can now rely on Super PACs to do their messaging dirty work, companies have long relied on think tanks to dirty the waters and sully opponents while maintaining clean hands. The only thing remarkable about the shameless shills at Heartland is that they are reliably more hyperbolic and effective than most.

Bill Kenealy is a senior editor for Insurance Networking News.

Readers are encouraged to respond to Bill by using the “Add Your Comments” box below. Healso can be reached at william.kenealy@sourcemedia.com.

This blog was exclusively written for Insurance Networking News. It may not be reposted or reused without permission from Insurance Networking News.

Comments (1)

Bill Kenealy,
You are smart enough to realize that the Heartland leak is probably fake.

How could you have missed the fact that there were no fake documents in Climategate I or II?

To compare Climategate with the Heartland leak is absurd.

Posted by: Peter M | February 21, 2012 12:06 PM

Report this Comment

Add Your Comments...

Already Registered?

If you have already registered to Insurance Networking News, please use the form below to login. When completed you will immeditely be directed to post a comment.

Forgot your password?

Not Registered?

You must be registered to post a comment. Click here to register.

Blog Archive

Mobile Device Management – Find That Middle Ground

There's a tug of war over BYOD, but neither those in favor nor those against should tug too hard.

Vendors Embrace Mobile Technology

IT leaders at software firms clearly recognize the importance of mobility to drive their businesses forward. Almost 70 percent see mobility as mission critical or important to their organization today.

Digital Vision vs. Harsh Reality

Much work remains to reconcile insurers' digital vision with the digital reality that seems to be arriving for other industries.

Big Data Is Paying Off

Insurers are getting business benefit out of their big data projects, but these projects alone won't grow their business.

What Can Insurers Learn from Home Depot?

The latest cyber-attack highlights the importance of helping policy holders defend themselves.

Not Your Father’s Insurance Company

Carriers need to look at new and impactful ways to be there for their customers.