PoCs - Protecting Your Investment With the Open Road Test

Catherine Stagg-Macey
Insurance Experts' Forum, February 17, 2010

In a recent conversation with a vendor, I was asked if there was any way in which we [Celent] could encourage/support the standardization of request for information documents sent out by insurers. Think ACORD Standards for RFIs! At the heart of her question, was a sense of deep frustration at the evaluation process which inhibits the vendor from highlighting or differentiating themselves. I have some sympathy with this view.

IT departments have become very good at comparing the data for RFI/RFPs in two-dimensions. A structured, transparent evaluation process is an important step in choosing what it likely to be a significant IT investment in the case of a core system replacement. The evaluation process can be used to generate hard facts highlighting the differences in system functionality, company and delivery options.

For many insurers, the governance process requires a presentation to the project sponsors of a detailed quantitative analysis of vendor submissions, along with ranking and weightings. This is all well and good but this output can be incorrectly attributed the status of a statistically sound scientific evaluation. I have seen projects where a vendor has been chosen because they had 2 more points in the final analysis on paper.

Most of us would not buy a car based solely on a review of features and functions on the manufacture’s Web site or brochure. We’d be out there driving and deliberating the real experience of the open road, handling of corners, and comfort of the seats. All these factors are almost impossible to quantify in a brochure but vital in influencing our final choice.

And it’s similar in the world of core system evaluation. The proof of concept PoC) is vital addendum to the evaluation process. This is the time to put the vendor to the test. This stage of the evaluation should allow the buyer to really see how easy the product configurator might be, how well a vendor can understand requirements, how responsive/ organised the vendor is, or how much/little coding is required.

And in Celent’s view, proof of concepts should be paid for. It shows the commitment on part of the insurer, and it also encourages the vendor to be focused and committed to this important step. Being paid allows the vendor to justify allocating top staff otherwise committed to paid implementations. A recent evaluation project paid 4-figure sums to both short-listed vendors for a 3 month proof of concept.

The proof of concept is a great process by which to garner more buy-in from the business users, and to generate some excitement about what this change could bring to the organization. Adding the open road test to the brochure comparison will undoubtedly help the insurer make a more robust decision.

This blog has been reprinted with permission from Celent. Catherine Stagg-Macey is a senior analyst in Celent's insurance practice, and can be reached at cstagg-macey@celent.com.

The opinions of bloggers on www.insurancenetworking.com do not necessarily reflect those of Insurance Networking News.

 

Comments (0)

Be the first to comment on this post using the section below.

Add Your Comments...

Already Registered?

If you have already registered to Insurance Networking News, please use the form below to login. When completed you will immeditely be directed to post a comment.

Forgot your password?

Not Registered?

You must be registered to post a comment. Click here to register.

Blog Archive

Don’t Wrap Your Organization Too Tight With Metrics

Metrics provide a picture of how business is going, and systems are performing. But do they provide the right picture?

Insurance: The Original Shared Economy

Insurers should look to revisit the roots of the insurance process.

The Seven Flavors of Virtualization

There is no one single form of virtualization rather, different parts of the IT infrastructure require different approaches.

Can New Technology Turn Older Cars into Safer Cars?

Unless you have the means and motivation to buy a new car every year, your newest car is quickly about to become an older car.

What if Someone Kickstarted an Insurance Company

Our industry is evolving and implementing new innovations, particularly focusing on the customer experience, including the web and mobile.

The Transformative CIO

Today's technology leaders are expanding well beyond their traditional role.